One Story of Salvation: The Covenants in Catholic Thought
This report explores the Catholic theological perspective on the relationship between the Old and New Testaments. The core principle is not that the New Covenant abolishes the Old, but rather that it brings it to its ultimate meaning and perfection in Jesus Christ. The Old Testament is indispensable, and its covenant has never been revoked. Christians believe God had one ongoing plan for salvation, revealed first to the Israelites and then to all peoples through Jesus Christ. The New Testament and Old Testament, therefore, tell one continuous story of salvation.
What is a Covenant?
In a theological sense, a covenant is a solemn, binding agreement that establishes a sacred family bond between God and humanity. It is much more than a contract; it creates a relationship of kinship and shared life.
The Progression of Covenants in Catholic Thought
Catholic theology understands God's relationship with humanity as a series of progressive covenants, or sacred bonds, that unfold over time. Each covenant builds upon the last, culminating in the final and definitive covenant established by Jesus Christ.
Old Covenants
These were the covenants made with figures like Noah, Abraham, and Moses. They were promises and laws that progressively prepared God's people for the Messiah. These covenants were real, but also preparatory and ultimately imperfect.
Christ as the Fulfillment
Jesus Christ is the ultimate fulfillment of all the Old Covenants. He is the New Adam, the ultimate priest, and the true King of the line of David. In Him, all of God's previous promises and plans find their intended meaning and perfection.
New & Eternal Covenant
Jesus establishes the New and Eternal Covenant through His death and resurrection. This covenant is not merely a legal agreement but a spiritual bond of grace, open to all humanity and intended to last forever, making the old covenants no longer necessary.
The Great Fulfillment
The Catholic Church teaches that Jesus Christ fulfills the central institutions of the Old Covenant—the Law, the Temple, and the Sacrificial system. He does not destroy them, but elevates them to their definitive, spiritual reality. Below is an exploration of how each element is transformed and perfected in the New Covenant.
The Law
Old Covenant: The Mosaic Law
God gave the Law to Moses on stone tablets. It was an external code of commandments, customs, and rituals that governed the life of the people of Israel.
-
📜
The Law as an External Code
A set of external rules for Israel to follow.
-
⚖️
Justice through Retribution
Enforced through strict penalties and an eye-for-an-eye mentality.
New Covenant: The Law of Christ
Jesus embodies and perfects the Law. He is the "Word made flesh."
-
❤️
The Law as Interior Grace
Written on the human heart by the Holy Spirit, enabling action from love.
-
🕊️
Justice through Mercy
Exemplified by Jesus' command to "turn the other cheek" and forgive enemies.
The Temple
Old Covenant: The Jerusalem Temple
The physical center of Israel's worship, God's dwelling place on Earth.
-
🏛️
A Physical Building
Worship was tied to a specific geographic location in Jerusalem.
-
🚪
Limited Access
The Holy of Holies was only accessible to the High Priest once a year.
New Covenant: The Body of Christ
Jesus is the true and definitive Temple of God.
-
👤
A Person, Not a Place
Worship now occurs "in spirit and in truth," accessible to all people everywhere.
-
🔓
Universal Access
The tearing of the Temple veil signifies direct access to God through Christ.
The Sacrifice
Old Covenant: Animal Sacrifices
The Law required repeated animal sacrifices for the temporary covering of sins.
-
🐑
Temporary and Repeated
Sacrifices were offered for each transgression, pointing to a future, perfect sacrifice.
-
🩸
Sacrifice of Animals
Animals were offered as a means of atonement.
New Covenant: The Sacrifice of Christ
Jesus offers Himself as the one, perfect, and eternal sacrifice.
-
✝️
Once-for-All and Eternal
Jesus' sacrifice on the Cross is the one perfect offering that covers all sins for all time.
-
🍞
Sacrifice of Christ (Eucharist)
He offers Himself, making further sacrifices obsolete. The Eucharist perpetuates this one sacrifice.
If the New Covenant fulfills the Old, why do we still read the Old Testament?
The Old Testament is not a discarded relic, but an indispensable and permanently valuable part of the Christian faith. It is essential for understanding the full story of salvation.
Historical Context
It provides the essential historical and cultural foundation for the New Testament, offering valuable insight into the Jewish customs and prophecies that enriched Jesus' life and teachings.
Moral Guidance
It is a treasure trove of moral and spiritual wisdom, with the Ten Commandments and Wisdom literature serving as foundational ethical codes that have shaped Christian moral teaching.
Typology
It contains significant typological value, where events and people (like the Passover lamb) prefigure what is fully realized in the New Testament through Christ, revealing the coherence of God's plan.
Liturgical Worship
The Old Testament plays a central role in Catholic liturgy and prayer, with readings at Mass and the Psalms forming the core of the Church's prayer life, making it a living part of the faith.
The New Ark of the Covenant
Typology, where an Old Testament reality prefigures a New Testament one, is key to understanding salvation history. The most sacred object of the Old Covenant, the Ark, is seen as a perfect type for the Blessed Virgin Mary, who carried the reality of God's presence within her.
The Ark of the Old Covenant
A vessel of pure gold, housing the signs of God's covenant with Israel.
-
📜
The Law of God
Contained the stone tablets of the Ten Commandments.
-
🍞
The Bread from Heaven
Contained a jar of manna, the miraculous food in the desert.
-
🌿
The High Priesthood
Contained the rod of Aaron, which budded as a sign of true priesthood.
Mary, The Ark of the New Covenant
The pure vessel chosen by God, housing the reality of the New Covenant.
-
🗣️
The Word Made Flesh
Carried Jesus, the living Word of God, who embodies the Law.
-
🍞
The True Bread of Life
Carried Jesus, the true Bread from Heaven given for the life of the world.
-
👑
The Eternal High Priest
Carried Jesus, the ultimate and eternal High Priest who offers Himself.
The New Israel
The "New Israel" is the Church, a universal people of God where "there is neither Jew nor Gentile." This does not nullify God's covenant with the Jewish people, but expands it to all humanity. This Catholic understanding differs significantly from some Protestant views, particularly regarding the modern state of Israel.
Common Christian Zionist View
-
View of Modern State:
Direct fulfillment of biblical prophecy.
-
Interpretation of Prophecy:
Literal, future-oriented (e.g., rebuilt Temple).
-
Divine Right to Land:
Affirms a divine right for Jews to the land now.
-
Relationship Focus:
Unconditional support for modern state of Israel.
Catholic View
-
View of Modern State:
Based on political reality, not theological fulfillment.
-
Interpretation of Prophecy:
Spiritual, fulfilled in Christ and the Church.
-
Divine Right to Land:
Rejects premise of a divine right to sovereignty today.
-
Relationship Focus:
Focus on unrevoked covenant and kinship with local Christians.
"The Church, the People of God of the New Covenant, is a spiritual community that 'draws sustenance from the root of that well-cultivated olive tree onto which the wild shoots, the Gentiles, have been grafted.' God's gifts and calling to the Jewish people are irrevocable, and they are not to be presented as rejected or accursed."
— Paraphrased from Nostra Aetate