Prayer as the Heart's Desire
An Exploration of Catholic Prayer
The Great Question About Prayer
A question many of us have is: Why should we pray? If God is all-knowing and already understands what we need even before we ask, it can seem like prayer is pointless. It feels like telling an all-knowing God what He already knows.
The great teacher St. Augustine offered a beautiful answer that has shaped Catholic understanding ever since. He explained that the purpose of prayer is not to inform God, but to transform us.
Prayer is an "exercise of desire." It's the process God gives us to "enlarge our hearts" and make us ready to receive the good gifts He has always wanted to give us. Through prayer, we change and grow, becoming spiritually ready for God's grace. This post explores this deep and beautiful understanding of prayer.
A Relationship, Not a Task
St. Augustine's idea of the "restless heart" is the foundation. He famously wrote that our hearts are restless until they rest in God. This restlessness is our built-in desire for God. Prayer is the exercise of that desire.
The Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC) builds on this foundation. It defines prayer as a "vital and personal relationship with the living and true God" (CCC 2558).
Here is how the ideas connect:
- God Calls First: The Catechism teaches that our desire for prayer is actually a response. God "tirelessly calls each person" to this relationship (CCC 2567).
- Our Response: Our restless heart is the imprint of God's call within us. We are restless because God is calling us.
- The Goal: Augustine's exercise of desire is the process of building our capacity for the vital relationship the Catechism describes. Prayer is how we make our hearts large enough to hold the love God wants to pour into them.
So, prayer is not just saying words. It is the living, breathing connection between God and us, a deep, two-way promise.
The Grammar of Prayer: Five Main Forms
The Church identifies five main ways our hearts can speak to God. These forms, outlined in the Catechism (CCC 2623-2649), give a "grammar" to our divine conversation. They are not separate boxes, but different movements of the heart that help us exercise our desire for God in all parts of our life.
This is the prayer of the creature acknowledging the Creator. Blessing is our fundamental response to God's gifts; because God blesses us, our hearts can bless Him in return. Adoration is the humble recognition of God's greatness and our own "dependence on Him in all things" (CCC 2628). It is the posture of Augustine's restless heart as it bows before the "rest" it was made for, worshipping God not for what He gives, but simply for who He is.
Note: This means the heart stops chasing worldly things and acknowledges that God is its true home. It surrenders to the only One who can satisfy it.
If we only pray to get things (health, money), we are using God as a means to an end. We are still "restless" because we really want the stuff, not Him.
Adoration is the moment we realize God is the prize. We aren't asking for a favour; we are just happy to be with Him. That is the "rest."
This is the most familiar form: asking God for help and for what we need. This is the prayer that sparked Augustine's great question. If God already knows, why ask? The Catholic answer is profound: petition is not about informing God, but about preparing us. The very act of asking turns our hearts toward God, reminds us of our dependence, and helps to order our desires. The Lord's Prayer is the perfect model, teaching us to first ask for the ultimate good ("Thy kingdom come") before asking for our daily needs ("our daily bread").
Intercession is a prayer of petition that "leads us to pray as Jesus did" (CCC 2634). It is the act of asking on behalf of others. This form of prayer shows the "enlarged heart" in action. When our desire for God grows, it stops being self-absorbed and overflows to include the good of others. This prayer "knows no boundaries" (CCC 2636) and can extend even to our enemies, joining us to the boundless, loving prayer of Christ for all humanity.
Examples:
- "Lord, bring comfort to my friend who is suffering."
- "For the leaders of our country, that they may govern with wisdom."
- "I pray for those who have hurt me, that they may find peace."
This is the prayer of gratitude. The Church calls us to "Give thanks in all circumstances." This form of prayer trains our hearts to see the world as a gift. "Every joy and suffering, every event and need can become the matter for thanksgiving" (CCC 2638). It is the "cry of recognition" that St. Thérèse spoke of, acknowledging that all is grace and that God is the Giver of all good things.
Praise is a form of prayer that is "entirely disinterested," meaning it is completely selfless. It "lauds God for his own sake and gives him glory... simply because HE IS" (CCC 2639). If Augustine's restless heart begins the journey of prayer, praise is the sound of that heart at rest. It is desire fulfilled. It is the unadulterated joy of "dwelling in the Lord's house," which was the one thing the Psalmist desired. It is the joyful overflow of a heart that has finally found its home in God.
Note on the Difference from Adoration: While Adoration and Praise are close cousins, they are distinct.
Adoration is the posture of the creature before the Creator. It focuses on our relationship and our dependence ("You are God, I am not").
Praise goes further. It is the song of the lover. It forgets itself entirely. It doesn't focus on "my" dependence or "my" needs; it focuses only on His beauty. Adoration bows down; Praise sings out.
The Journey of Prayer: Three Expressions
The Church's tradition shows a path for our life of prayer. These are three ways we practise prayer, moving from the outside in.
- 1. Vocal Prayer This is prayer that uses words, either spoken or in our minds (like the Our Father, the Rosary, or our own spontaneous words). As human beings, we are body and spirit, so we need to express our feelings externally. This is the first step, and it can lead to deeper prayer when we become aware of who we are speaking to (CCC 2700-2704).
-
2. Meditation
This is a prayerful quest (CCC 2705). Unlike Eastern forms of meditation that seek to empty the mind, Christian meditation seeks to fill the mind. It actively engages our thought, imagination, emotion, and desire.
Think of it as a "spiritual workshop." We might read a scripture passage (Lectio Divina) and imagine ourselves in the scene, or reflect on a mystery of the Rosary. We "chew" on these truths to make them our own. The goal is not just to learn, but to move our hearts to love and strengthen our will to follow Christ. It is the active work of preparing our hearts.
-
3. Contemplative Prayer
If meditation is the active "quest," contemplation is the receptive "gift." It is the most simple and deep expression of prayer. The Catechism calls it a gaze of faith fixed on Jesus and a silent love.
In contemplation, we move beyond words and active thoughts. We stop "doing" and simply start "being" with God. St. Teresa of Ávila described it beautifully as a "close sharing between friends," where we take time to be alone with Him who we know loves us. It is the moment the "restless heart" stops searching for words and simply rests in the presence of the Beloved. It is a communion of love.
How to Pray Without Ceasing
St. Paul gives us a challenging command: "Pray without ceasing." If prayer meant only speaking words, this would be impossible. We have to sleep, work, and care for others.
St. Augustine offers a liberating solution based on the idea of the heart's desire. He says, "Desire without intermission" is the same as "pray without ceasing."
As long as our heart cherishes a deep desire for God and for the "happy life" He offers, our prayer continues even while we are silent or busy with other tasks. This "holy desire" is a constant song our heart sings to God.
Why, then, do we need set times for prayer? If desire is enough, why go to Mass or say morning prayers? Augustine explains that the cares of the world can cool our hearts. We need specific times of vocal prayer and attention to God to "stir the flame" of our desire. These moments remind us of what we truly want and prevent our love from growing lukewarm or cold. The set prayers feed the unceasing fire of desire.
The Source and Summit: The Eucharist
While personal prayer is vital, the Church teaches that the Eucharist is the "source and summit" of the Christian life. It is not just one way to pray; it is the heartbeat of all prayer.
In the Mass, all the "forms" of prayer we have discussed come together in a single act of worship. We ask for forgiveness (Petition), we listen to God's word (Meditation), we offer gifts (Thanksgiving), and we sing "Holy, Holy, Holy" (Praise).
Most importantly, in the Eucharist, we are not praying alone. We are united with the perfect prayer of Jesus to the Father. When we receive Him, our "restless hearts" find the true Bread of Life, the only food that can truly satisfy our infinite hunger. It is here that our desire meets God's desire for us in the most profound way possible.
What About "Unanswered" Prayers?
We have all experienced praying for something specific, like for healing, for a different outcome, or for help, and not receiving what we asked for. This can feel like our prayers are unanswered or that God is silent.
The saints and teachers of the Church offer a beautiful perspective on this. They teach that in God's economy, no sincere prayer ever goes unanswered. The answer, however, may not be the one we were expecting.
Sometimes God's answer is "no," or "not yet," because His wisdom sees a greater good that we cannot. But more profoundly, the saints understood that the ultimate answer to every prayer is God Himself.
The very act of turning to God in prayer is an exercise of desire that deepens our relationship with Him. St. Teresa of Ávila taught that prayer is a close sharing between friends. The true gift of prayer is not always getting what we want, but the friendship and intimacy with God that grows from the conversation.
Every time we pray, our hearts are enlarged, just as Augustine said. We are drawn closer to God, learn to trust Him more, and are slowly conformed to His will. This deeper relationship, this trust, and this change in our own heart is the true answer to our prayer. God always gives us Himself, which is the greatest gift and the only one our restless hearts truly seek.
The Life of Prayer
From a Catholic perspective, prayer is not just one activity among many. It is a "vital necessity" (CCC 2744), the "life of the new heart" (CCC 2697). It is the relationship with Jesus Christ Himself.
This life of prayer begins with recognising our restless heart. It is defined as a vital relationship with God. We are given a grammar to speak with Him (the five forms) and a path to follow (the three expressions). This journey may be guided by reason, but it leads to a relationship of love, finding its simplest expression in a surge of the heart that finally finds its rest in God.